In Sanchez v. State, the Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the defendant’s convictions for child molestation, holding that the defendant failed to prove that his trial attorney was deficient for failing to request a jury charge on sexual battery as a lesser included offense of child molestation.
The Court noted that when deciding whether trial counsel’s performance was deficient, it “must indulge a strong presumption that counsel’s conduct falls within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance.” A defendant also must show “a reasonable probability of a different outcome” as a result of the deficient performance.
The defendant argued that counsel was deficient because he failed to request that the jury be permitted to consider the lesser included offense of sexual battery. At a hearing on the defendant’s motion for new trial, the trial attorney testified that the defendant and counsel had decided on an “all-or-nothing” strategy—hoping that the jury would find the evidence insufficient for a child molestation conviction. The attorney also testified that the defendant told him that a sexual battery conviction may make it more likely that the defendant would then be prosecuted for illegally re-entering the United States. It was based on these conversations that counsel chose not to request a sexual battery charge.
The Court of Appeals has previously held that the decision not to request jury instructions on a lesser included offense is a matter of trial strategy that is “best left to the judgment of counsel after consultation with a client.” The Court held that the evidence authorized the trial court to find that counsel made a reasonable strategic decision after consulting with the defendant. Therefore, the Court held that counsel’s performance was not deficient.
In Wilson v. State, the defendant appealed his convictions for two counts of incest, one count of statutory rape, and…May 11, 2020 Court Holds That Molestation Plea May be Withdrawn Due to Void Sentence
The Georgia Court of Appeals held that the defendant had a right to withdraw his guilty plea to two counts…April 2, 2020 Pregnancy May Constitute Physical Injury Element of Aggravated Child Molestation
In Daddario v. State, the Georgia Supreme Court held that a child victim’s pregnancy and difficult childbirth could be sufficient…