Brody Law Firm

Call(404) 577-9557Menu
  • Firm
  • Practice
  • Cases
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Media
  • Contact

Our Blog

Child’s Therapy Records Form Basis for Reversal in Molestation Case

April 25, 2018 in Georgia Child Molestation Cases

In Gonzales v. State, the Georgia Court of Appeals reversed the defendant’s convictions for aggravated sexual battery and child molestation finding that his trial counsel was ineffective for failing to properly elicit testimony regarding the alleged victim’s character for untruthfulness.

The alleged victim accused the defendant of touching her on several occasions when she was between the ages of seven and thirteen. The alleged victim’s therapy records were obtained by the trial court and made a part of the record on appeal. The records contained therapist’s notes that the child  had “a history of lying to her mother” and that the mother had told the therapist that she could not trust her because she “constantly lies to her and does things to be vindictive.”

The trial attorney testified that she believed that the best way to bring out this evidence was by asking the alleged victim on cross examination, “Do you always tell the truth?” and“[Do you] tell the truth to figures of authority?” The court would not permit trial counsel to ask those questions, noting that O.C.G.A. § 24-6-608 only permitted questions concerning “specific instances of conduct” on cross examination.

The proper way to elicit this testimony would be by questioning the mother about her opinion of the child’s character for untruthfulness. Trial counsel testified that she was not aware that she could ask the mother about this without first questioning the child. The Court found that trial counsel was mistaken and that the mother’s opinion about the child’s untruthfulness was admissible regardless of whether the child testified about it.

As a result, the Court found that “trial counsel’s performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness.” The Court added that the evidence was not overwhelming and the alleged victim’s statements were not completely consistent. Considering that the alleged victim’s credibility was crucial to the State’s case, the Court concluded that there is a reasonable probability that counsel’s error affected the outcome of the trial.

Therefore, the Court reversed the defendant’s aggravated sexual battery and child molestation convictions and remanded the case for a new trial.

More Posts in Georgia Child Molestation Cases

Court Approves Defense’s Use of Rape Shield But Overrules Decades of Case Law

February 8, 2019

The Georgia Supreme Court recently held in White v. State that the Rape Shield Statute may be invoked by the defense to exclude evidence of prior sexual conduct of the alleged victim that the State wishes to introduce at trial. In this case, the State sought to introduce evidence that the alleged child victim was…

Supreme Court to Review Admissibility of Prior False Allegations

January 10, 2019

The Georgia Supreme Court has granted certiorari in Burns v. State where the Court of Appeals held that the trial court erred in excluding evidence that the alleged victim had made a prior false allegation of sexual abuse against someone other than the defendant. This has the potential to be a major decision affecting the…

Aggravated Sexual Battery Conviction Reversed Due to Jury Charge Error

December 31, 2018

In Croft v. State, the Georgia Court of Appeals reversed the defendant’s aggravated sexual battery conviction finding that the instructions to the jury relieved the State of its burden to prove that the alleged act was committed without the consent of the child. The Defendant was accused of molesting his 15-year-old niece and he was…

Load More Posts…

Blog Categories

  • Firm News
  • Georgia Child Molestation Cases
  • Georgia Child Pornography Cases
  • Georgia Computer Exploitation Cases
  • Georgia Enticement Cases
  • Georgia Rape Cases
  • Georgia Search and Seizure Cases
  • Georgia Sex Offender Registry Cases
  • Georgia Sexting Cases
  • Georgia Sexual Assault Cases
  • Legal News

Brody Law Firm

Contact Us

1180 West Peachtree Street, Suite 2075, Atlanta, GA 30309
(404) 577-9557

© Brody Law Firm